Though he's in no way related to Richard or Karen, another Carpenter has carved out quite a niche for himself in the world of film music in addition to his work behind the camera. We are of course referring to John, whose father's own teaching career in the subject proved inspiration enough for him to compose as well as direct - making him the ideal case study as we now look at the blurring of the line between sound & vision.
Amazingly he's been combining both roles since his first short feature, 1970's The Resurrection Of Broncho Billy, a Western. Dark Star, released just four years later, represented his full length maiden outing - its score composed using only synthesisers. And in January this year it got a timely reissue!
An interview with FACT reveals that it wasn't solely an artistic decision to do so....
"My decision to use synthesizers was born out of necessity. And because when you’re a student filmmaker or a low-budget filmmaker you really don’t have any budget, so you can’t afford to hire a great composer or an orchestra and a recording studio, so what I decided to do was use a synthesizer because you could sound big with just a keyboard – with multiple tracks – so that’s how it started. Then over the years it evolved into another form of directing, another form of creating."A creative process which would quicken by the time Assault On Precinct 13 came into being. That particular score was written in just three days inspired by Lalo Schfrin's work on Dirty Harry.
Things start to get even more interesting in consideration of Halloween, his 1978 slasher later remade under the directorship of one Rob Zombie, who before moving behind the camera was on a vaguely similar path to Carpenter. Zombie was a musician in his own right both as leader of White Zombie & a solo artist.
Zombie's remake was universally derided. Its soundtrack replaced Carpenter's original music with a selection of the director's favourites including Halloween II by horror punks Misfits, Rush's Tom Sawyer & Bachman Turner Overdrive's Let It Ride. Alongside that is a Tyler Bates reimagining of the original main theme, of which John remembered,
“It was just something I’d tinkered out on the piano. I played 5/4 time on an octave on a piano, that’s all it was. I hadn’t necessarily applied it to Halloween, it was just sitting there and I thought, Oh, I’ll use this. That works okay. I’m not an accomplished composer of symphonies, I just do basic, straight-ahead, riff-driven music.”
1982's The Thing found his foot being taken off the musical pedal as all such duties were handed over to Ennio Morricone, though the two collaborated through the universal language of music without actually sharing a common tongue. Carpenter saw Ennio as something of an idol, but he wasn't happy with the finished work. Alan Howarth, one of the men brought in to collaborate on a re-recording, would reveal it wasn't an easy time for the horror auteur.
“So, here’s John Carpenter, who did Escape From New York, and he gets this big opportunity to do a remake of his favourite director Howard Hawks’ The Thing' and the bandwidth is there to hire Ennio Morricone. So he goes ahead, makes his movie – it’s a very difficult movie to make; it had a lot of challenges – and Ennio goes off and scores it. The score comes back, and John kind of wrote it off to: ‘How do I tell my hero that I don’t like what he did?’
It was the English to Italian, and he didn’t understand it. So then he plays for Morricone the score we did for Escape From New York. And there’s another version where the Thing theme is very successful. And even after that, Ennio gave it out two passes. John comes from the other side; he says: ‘Hmm, there’s a couple of things I really need. You mind if we just kind of go to the studio for a day and sneak this one in?’ We did three more cues, making it more John Carpenter-esque…”
Fast forward to 2015 and after composing music for almost two dozen films, Carpenter released his debut studio album. A second volume followed in 2016, both of them collecting together some of his extra curricular activities produced alongside son Cody & godson Daniel Davies - himself the son of Dave Davies of the Kinks, he of the amp-slashing antics which created the famed riff to You Really Got Me.
For Carpenter the pressure was off!
"It can be both great and bad to score over images, which is what I’m used to. Here there were no pressures. No actors asking me what they’re supposed to do. No crew waiting. No cutting room to go to. No release pending. It’s just fun. And I couldn’t have a better set-up at my house, where I depended on Cody and Daniel to bring me ideas as we began improvising.
The plan was to make my music more complete and fuller, because we had unlimited tracks. I wasn’t dealing with just analogue anymore. It’s a brand new world."A brand new world, but one which could stand within any of his horror soundscapes.