First broadcast in November 1986, Terror of the Vervoids marks the third segment of The Trial of a Time Lord. Written by Pip and Jane Baker and directed by Chris Clough, this four-part serial represents a shift in tone from its predecessor, Mindwarp, opting for a classic murder mystery set aboard a starliner. It also serves as the introduction of the Sixth Doctor’s new companion, Melanie Bush, played by Bonnie Langford. While Terror of the Vervoids attempts to bring back a sense of traditional Doctor Who adventure, its reliance on genre tropes, uneven execution, and rushed character introduction make it a fascinating but flawed entry in the Trial arc.
The framing device of the trial continues, but this time, the Doctor presents evidence from his future in an attempt to defend himself against the Valeyard’s accusations. The story is set aboard the space liner Hyperion III, where the Doctor and Mel arrive just as mysterious deaths begin occurring among the crew and passengers. As the investigation unfolds, they discover that the ship is harboring a deadly secret—the Vervoids, a race of plant-based humanoids with a sinister agenda. What begins as a murder mystery quickly spirals into a battle for survival, with the Doctor attempting to prevent a full-scale ecological disaster.
Colin Baker’s performance in Terror of the Vervoids is noticeably more restrained compared to his previous stories. This iteration of the Sixth Doctor, while still possessing his signature confidence, is less abrasive and more measured in his approach. The decision to tone down his character traits may have been a conscious effort to address previous criticisms, and while it does make him a more traditionally heroic figure, it also diminishes some of the uniqueness that made his portrayal stand out.
The introduction of Bonnie Langford’s Mel is one of the serial’s more contentious aspects. Unlike previous companions, Mel is introduced without an origin story—her presence aboard the TARDIS is simply taken as fact, with no explanation of how she met the Doctor or why she is traveling with him. This jarring transition makes it difficult to immediately invest in her character, though Langford brings an undeniable energy to the role. Mel’s upbeat personality and enthusiasm for fitness (including her infamous encouragement for the Doctor to exercise) provide a stark contrast to Peri, but her character is not given enough depth to establish a strong emotional connection.
The Vervoids themselves are an intriguing but flawed creation. Conceptually, the idea of a race of sentient plants who perceive humanity as a threat is strong, drawing from classic science fiction themes of nature rebelling against its oppressors. However, their execution is hampered by unconvincing costumes and an overly simplistic approach to their motivations. While their eerie whispering and method of attack—releasing toxic spores—add an element of body horror, their overall presence is more awkward than menacing.
The murder mystery structure of the story is engaging, borrowing heavily from Agatha Christie-style whodunits. The confined setting of the Hyperion III provides a natural tension, and the various crew members and passengers serve as effective suspects. However, the pacing feels rushed, and some of the character arcs are underdeveloped, making it difficult to fully invest in the intrigue. The presence of Rudge, the ship’s security officer turned reluctant conspirator, adds an interesting layer to the plot, but his motivations and eventual downfall feel abrupt.
Visually, Terror of the Vervoids is a step up from previous entries in Season 23, with well-designed spaceship interiors and effective use of lighting to create atmosphere. The sequences featuring the Vervoids attacking the crew are competently staged, but the limited effects budget occasionally undercuts the tension. The Hyperion III itself is a convincing setting, though it lacks the distinctive visual identity that could have made it more memorable.
Thematically, the story explores issues of genetic engineering, ecological balance, and the consequences of scientific hubris. The Vervoids’ desire for survival is understandable, but their willingness to exterminate all animal life makes them a morally complex threat. The Doctor’s ultimate decision to destroy them—a move that the Valeyard seizes upon as evidence of genocide—raises questions about ethical responsibility, though the story does not delve deeply enough into the ramifications of this choice.
Rewatching Terror of the Vervoids in 2025, it remains an entertaining but uneven entry in the Sixth Doctor’s era. The attempt to return to a more traditional adventure format is welcome, but the trial framework continues to disrupt the story’s flow. The Doctor’s defensive position, forced to justify his actions while the Valeyard twists the narrative against him, adds a layer of tension but also creates a sense of detachment from the events being depicted.
The serial’s climax, with the Doctor eliminating the Vervoids and saving the remaining passengers, is action-packed but lacks a strong emotional payoff. The reveal that the Valeyard intends to use the Doctor’s actions as proof of his guilt adds an intriguing twist, but the execution of this revelation feels abrupt rather than shocking. The story ultimately serves more as a functional piece of the Trial arc rather than a standout adventure in its own right.
The Trial of a Time Lord continues to be a double-edged sword, adding intrigue while simultaneously hampering each individual story’s ability to fully breathe. Terror of the Vervoids is a step in the right direction in terms of tone and pacing, but it never quite reaches the heights of classic Doctor Who mysteries. It is a story that works in parts but fails to leave a lasting impact.
No comments:
Post a Comment