After the emotional intensity of The God Complex, Closing Time (first broadcast on 24 September 2011) offers a gentler, more character-driven interlude. Written by Gareth Roberts and directed by Steve Hughes, it brings back Craig Owens (James Corden) from The Lodger for a second outing alongside Matt Smith’s Eleventh Doctor. Rewatching in 2025, it’s clear that while this isn’t one of the series’ deeper philosophical explorations, it succeeds on its own terms — as a light, heartfelt story about friendship, fatherhood, and the quieter ways the Doctor touches people’s lives.
Set a few centuries after The God Complex, the episode finds the Doctor travelling alone, preparing for his impending death at Lake Silencio. When he visits Craig, now a new father struggling to balance parenthood and self-confidence, the story finds humour and warmth in their unlikely dynamic. The contrast between the Doctor’s cosmic melancholy and Craig’s domestic chaos creates much of the episode’s charm.
Matt Smith and James Corden’s chemistry remains strong. Their easy banter and comic timing carry the episode through its lighter moments, yet there’s real emotional weight beneath the humour. Smith’s Doctor, masking sorrow with whimsy, is clearly visiting Craig for comfort as much as companionship. There’s something tender in the way he tries to convince himself that the universe will manage without him. “It’s fine,” he insists, though we know it isn’t.
James Corden plays Craig with likeable sincerity. He’s not a hero or a genius — just an ordinary man trying to do right by his family. His fears about failing as a father feel honest and grounded. The Doctor’s encouragement — that Craig is already enough simply because he cares — gives the story its emotional centre. In contrast to the cosmic morality of The God Complex, Closing Time celebrates everyday courage. Saving the world here isn’t about grand gestures; it’s about showing up, even when you’re tired and uncertain.
The subplot involving the Cybermen is fairly straightforward, and while it lacks the menace of their more memorable appearances, it serves its purpose. The Cybermen’s reactivation beneath a department store works as a solid backdrop for the human story rather than as its main event. The setting itself — all fluorescent lighting, shop-floor banter, and awkward customer service smiles — is familiar and faintly absurd, giving the episode a recognisably British tone. Roberts has always excelled at finding humour in the mundane, and here he blends it neatly with science fiction threat.
The supporting cast adds colour to the story. Daisy Haggard returns briefly as Sophie, Craig’s partner, while Lynda Baron (returning to Doctor Who decades after her Enlightenment appearance) shines as Val, the sharp-tongued shop assistant who mistakes the Doctor and Craig for a couple. Her deadpan delivery gives the episode some of its funniest lines. The idea of the Doctor blending into retail life — scanning groceries, chatting with customers, wearing a name badge — continues the domestic surrealism that made The Lodger so enjoyable.
What gives Closing Time longevity is its emotional honesty. The climactic moment — when Craig resists Cyber-conversion after hearing his baby’s cries — might sound sentimental, but it works because it’s rooted in character rather than spectacle. Love doesn’t magically save the day; it simply reminds Craig who he is. The Doctor’s joy and relief at seeing father and son reunited feel genuine, especially given his own sense of impending loss. The story subtly parallels the Doctor’s loneliness with Craig’s fear of inadequacy. Both men, in their own way, are learning that connection matters more than control.
Visually, the episode is modest but effective. The muted lighting of the Cybermen’s lair contrasts well with the bright artificiality of the shop above, reinforcing the divide between the ordinary and the extraordinary. Steve Hughes keeps the pacing brisk and the tone balanced, allowing moments of comedy and melancholy to coexist naturally. Murray Gold’s score adds warmth, particularly in the quieter scenes between the Doctor and baby Alfie (or, as the Doctor insists, “Stormageddon, Dark Lord of All”). Those brief, whimsical exchanges between the Doctor and the baby remain among the episode’s most endearing touches — small reminders of how effortlessly Matt Smith conveyed empathy through humour.
Rewatching in 2025, Closing Time feels like a calm breath before the storm of the season finale. It’s a story about human resilience, about how small acts of care can stand against fear. For the Doctor, it’s a reminder of why he travels — not to wage wars or solve cosmic puzzles, but to witness the beauty of ordinary lives. For Craig, it’s about recognising that love, in its everyday form, is enough to face the universe.
If the episode feels slight compared to its neighbours, that’s part of its appeal. Not every Doctor Who story needs to change the mythos or break hearts. Sometimes, it just needs to make you smile, to remind you that kindness counts. Closing Time achieves that with sincerity and warmth, earning its place as a small but meaningful chapter in the Eleventh Doctor’s journey.
No comments:
Post a Comment