Episode three of Black Mirror Season 7, Hotel Reverie, is a tragic sci-fi reverie in itself: a haunting, layered episode that unfolds with all the delicate melancholy of a doomed romance and the razor-edge commentary of the series at its best. This is Charlie Brooker returning to the conceptual wellspring of San Junipero and Be Right Back, but spinning something even more emotionally ambivalent and narratively disorienting. It's a love story—yes—but one filtered through AI, vintage cinema, and the surreal theatre of self-perception.
Issa Rae leads the episode as Brandy Friday, an A-list actor at the top of her game who, perhaps more out of boredom than conviction, agrees to take on a role in a high-tech remake of a beloved 1940s romantic classic. But she’ll only do it on one condition: that she plays a gender-bending version of the male love interest, Dr. Alex Palmer. From the start, we’re in layered meta-territory—one story nested inside another, both bent around the complicated intersections of identity, performance, and authorship.
The twist? This isn’t a movie set. This is ReDream, a deeply uncanny virtual environment where Brandy’s consciousness is uploaded into a simulation of the original film. There are no actors, only replicas of characters from the 1940s movie—digitally recreated personas guided by machine learning. Brandy’s job is to embody Palmer, hit the narrative beats, and speak the final line of the film to cue the credits and escape.
What follows is an exquisitely spiralling descent into digital chaos. Brandy can’t play piano—a crucial element in the original story. As a result, the romantic lead Clara, played by a stunning Emma Corrin, doesn’t respond as she should. The narrative skews. The program stutters. Clara begins to break free of her loops. Worse, Brandy mistakenly refers to Clara by the name of her original actress, Dorothy Chambers—an error that imbues the character with memories from Dorothy’s life.
It’s a sharp bit of writing. The romantic plot isn’t just diverging from the film—it’s mutating. Clara begins to remember being Dorothy, a tortured, possibly closeted actress from Hollywood’s Golden Age who died by suicide. Her glitching consciousness becomes the emotional engine of the story, her reality fractured between artifice and memory. Corrin plays her with a poignant fragility, haunted but lucid, aware of her pain but unsure if it's hers to claim.
When the simulation crashes after a spilled coffee incident—because of course—it strands Brandy and Clara in this purgatorial version of the film’s world. With the production team severed from the feed, Brandy has no script, no instructions, no performance to mimic. All that remains is the intimacy between her and Clara.
And so, in the frozen filmic dreamscape, a new story unfolds. For months (minutes in the real world), Brandy and Clara live together. They kiss. They talk. They grieve. Brandy begins to question if what they have is real, or just another echo of programming. Clara, heartbreakingly, can’t answer. Love in a simulation—does it count? Can it hurt you less for being coded?
The real tragedy hits when the simulation is restored. The producers, unaware of what has transpired, reset everything back to the point before Clara gained agency. The months Brandy lived with her, loved her, are deleted. Clara is back to being Clara: demure, subservient, bound to the script. For Brandy, it’s like watching someone you love die and be replaced with their twin.
Still, the show must go on. Brandy, shattered, finishes the film. And in the climax, something unexpected happens. Clara deviates again. She kills her husband to save Brandy and is shot by the police. In Brandy’s arms, she dies as Brandy utters the final line. It’s not the scripted end. It’s something truer, more painful. A final spark of the Clara she knew.
What lingers is the aftermath. Brandy, now back in her penthouse, lives with the ghost of an artificial lover. She opens a gift from the producers: a sleek, retro-styled telephone that lets her communicate with Clara’s consciousness. It’s both touching and horrifying. A lifeline. A prison.
What Hotel Reverie does so well is refuse to pick a side. It doesn’t declare AI love fake, nor does it glorify it. It recognises that emotion is real when it feels real—even if it was sparked by a line of code or a rogue piano scene. The episode uses lush cinematography and noir-inflected visuals to mirror the glamour and heartbreak of classic Hollywood, with Brooker's script slyly interrogating the cost of immortality and the ethics of emotional simulation.
Issa Rae is extraordinary here, shedding her natural charisma for something more brittle and haunted. Her Brandy is not cold, but tired—aching for something authentic even as she drowns in make-believe. And Emma Corrin’s Clara/Dorothy is equally brilliant, evoking an old-Hollywood sorrow that never quite fades.
This isn’t the sharpest, most political Black Mirror episode. But it may be one of the most emotionally rich. Like the best speculative fiction, it uses impossible technology to explore the most human questions: What does it mean to be remembered? What does it mean to choose love? Can something programmed feel like fate?
In the end, Hotel Reverie doesn’t break your heart. It leaves it humming, low and constant, like a song only you can hear. And in true Black Mirror fashion, it doesn’t answer the question it poses. It just lets you sit with it.
Love, it seems, is the most dangerous simulation of all.
No comments:
Post a Comment