First broadcast in September 1989, Battlefield marks the 152nd adventure in Doctor Who and serves as the opening serial for the show’s 26th and final classic-era season. Written by Ben Aaronovitch and directed by Michael Kerrigan, this four-part story ambitiously merges Arthurian legend with a modern-day military setting. Featuring the return of Nicholas Courtney as Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart, it carries both nostalgic weight and thematic depth. However, its execution is uneven, with some pacing issues and production limitations holding it back from achieving its full potential.
The story begins with the Doctor and Ace arriving in England, where a UNIT force led by Brigadier Bambera is investigating mysterious disturbances linked to an ancient battlefield. As it turns out, the legends of King Arthur are not merely myths—Morgaine, an interdimensional sorceress, has arrived with her knights to claim Excalibur, believing the Doctor to be Merlin. With the return of the retired Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart and an all-out war brewing between supernatural and military forces, the Doctor must balance diplomacy, strategy, and magic to prevent catastrophe.
Sylvester McCoy’s Doctor is at his most enigmatic here, fully embracing the mysterious and mythical aura that was steadily developing in his character. The idea that the Doctor has a past—or, more accurately, a future—role as Merlin plays into the overarching theme of him being a figure who exists outside of traditional timelines. McCoy’s performance is confident and layered, with moments of warmth toward Ace, steel in the face of danger, and quiet amusement at the unfolding events. The contrast between his nonviolent approach and the military action surrounding him adds a compelling layer to his character’s philosophy.
Sophie Aldred’s Ace continues to shine, proving once again that she is one of the most fully realized companions of the classic era. Her rapport with the Brigadier, her fearless attitude in battle, and her defiance in the face of authority make her a perfect companion for this incarnation of the Doctor. The moment where she pulls Excalibur from its resting place—taking on a role traditionally reserved for Arthurian heroes—reinforces her growth and importance within the Doctor’s world.
Nicholas Courtney’s return as Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart is a highlight of the serial. His presence instantly elevates the story, adding a sense of history and continuity to the ever-changing world of Doctor Who. The chemistry between McCoy’s Doctor and the Brigadier is wonderfully nuanced—there is mutual respect, but also an acknowledgment of how much things have changed since their previous encounters. His final stand against the Destroyer is a powerful moment, showcasing his bravery and reminding audiences why he remains one of the show’s most beloved characters.
Jean Marsh delivers a commanding performance as Morgaine, bringing both gravitas and tragedy to the role. Unlike many one-note villains, Morgaine is portrayed as an honorable adversary, bound by her own sense of warrior’s code. Her moments of reflection—such as her grief upon realizing her son has been killed—add depth to her character, making her one of the more compelling antagonists of the McCoy era. However, her motivations and backstory could have been explored further, as the script occasionally treats her more as a plot device than a fully developed character.
The supporting cast is a mixed bag. Brigadier Bambera, played by Angela Bruce, is a strong presence but lacks the characterization needed to make her feel fully integrated into the story. Her relationship with Ancelyn, one of Morgaine’s knights, is underdeveloped, though it adds a lighter, romantic element to the narrative.
Visually, Battlefield is ambitious, but the execution is hampered by budgetary constraints. The outdoor filming gives the story a grander scope, but certain effects—such as the Destroyer, Morgaine’s monstrous enforcer—are inconsistent. While the practical costume design for the Destroyer is impressive, his limited screen time and the hurried nature of his defeat make him feel like a missed opportunity. The battle sequences, while ambitious for the time, lack the scale needed to truly sell the idea of a war between worlds.
Thematically, Battlefield explores the intersection of myth and reality, the legacy of war, and the power of honor and diplomacy. The Doctor’s refusal to engage in violence, contrasted with the militaristic approach of UNIT and the warriors from Morgaine’s realm, underscores the show’s long-running message about alternative solutions to conflict. The story also reinforces the idea that the Doctor exists beyond linear time, with his Merlin identity suggesting a broader and more complex personal history than previously thought.
Rewatching Battlefield in 2025, it remains an engaging but flawed serial. The ambitious blending of science fiction and mythology is commendable, and the return of the Brigadier gives it an emotional weight that many other stories lack. However, the pacing issues, uneven effects, and underdeveloped secondary characters prevent it from reaching the heights of the best McCoy-era stories. That said, it is an important step in the Seventh Doctor’s development, continuing the era’s shift toward deeper lore and a more mythic interpretation of the character.
As Doctor Who moved into its final season of the classic era, Battlefield set the stage for the increasing complexity and darkness that would define the McCoy years. With more mysteries surrounding the Doctor and a continued emphasis on themes of destiny and legacy, the journey toward the show’s 1989 finale was well underway.
No comments:
Post a Comment